Rushville Republican

Church

December 27, 2013

Choose the future

Last year the Old South Congregational Church in Boston began to unravel itself from a quandary. They had been the longtime owners of an exceptional church hymnal, one of the first books produced in North America, printed in 1640. After years of deliberation, study groups, and business meetings, the church finally voted to sell the hymnal.

Because of the age and historical importance attached to this hymnal, selling it was much more than jettisoning a tiny sliver of American nostalgia. The hymnal has incredible value for collectors, and those collectors were salivating to sink their teeth into this ancient book. Thus, when Sotheby’s auctioned the hymnal last month, it brought a hammer price of $14.2 million, a record for a single printed book.

The sale price, with that long string of zeros, did not free the church from controversy. On one side were the church historians and those members of the congregation who felt they had been called to preserve the church’s history and legacy. On the other side were Pastor Nancy Taylor, the majority of the leadership, and those who felt that faithful stewardship demanded that the resources of the church not be preserved but repurposed to continue mission and ministry.

One side said it was about symbolism, while the other side said it was about service. One side said it was about the past, while the other side pointed to the future. One side said it was about greed on the behalf of the church’s leadership, and the church leadership said the dissenters were moored to traditionalism.

I watched this story unfold for over a year, and was sympathetic to both sides until I heard the church historian say that the church had two of these exceptional books and if this one was sold, “You would never be able to hold one in each hand ever again.” Of course, he had to admit that holding them was not really practical – they are much too fragile for that.

Text Only
Church
  • It was a shoofly pie celebration weekend People ask me questions all the time. Some of those questions I can answer, some I cannot answer and some I will not answer. I wish people would ask me questions I could answer and look good about it. However, it never happens.The Gracious Mistress o

    August 22, 2014

  • chu-rv082214-church mouse logo Angel the Church Mouse Hi, all you kind folks in Readership Land,In my “scramin’” about, I came across something I’d seen many moons ago. All of us are guilty of whining, it’s “our nature”, as the saying goes. We don’t mean to be a bore to others-we just whine when we “ott

    August 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • chu-rv082214-new pastor pic Holy Trinity Lutheran Church welcomes new pastor Holy Trinity Lutheran Church (Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod), since Oct. 12, 1935, has been growing in its worship and service and are happy to welcome newly-ordained Pastor Aaron West and his family to Greensburg as the newest members of Holy Tri

    August 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • 'Keeping the Faith': Wise Up When a mother giraffe gives birth, she will do so while standing up. So her calf’s first act is to fall six feet to the ground, crash landing on his face. Then, as if such an arrival wasn’t harsh enough, the youngling’s mother will continually knock

    August 22, 2014

  • Church Briefs First Baptist Church of Rushville“Objects in mirror are closer than they appear.” I noticed these words on the rear view mirror of the car in which I was riding. Just to see the difference of perspective, I turned my head around to see how far behind

    August 22, 2014

  • Keeping the Faith: 'The Preacher' I grew up with a lot of religious rules. To violate these rules was to subject oneself to the judgment of God. If you had a fundamentalist upbringing, you may be familiar with some of these restrictions. No drinking, no smoking, no dancing, no playin

    August 15, 2014

  • Church Briefs First Baptist Church of RushvilleSometimes it is difficult to know who you can trust. Someone at first sight may seem like a trustworthy person, but when you least expect it, you get blindsided. Even the most trustworthy person may let you down somet

    August 15, 2014

  • Religion briefs Gay SD prep coach will keep job at private schoolDELL RAPIDS, S.D. (AP) - A volleyball coach at a private Catholic school in South Dakota who has publicly announced he’s gay says he’s being allowed to keep his job.Nate Alfson announced he was gay las

    August 15, 2014

  • Two words that changed my life This week is a hallmark in the lives of the Gracious Mistress of the Parsonage and me. Forty-three years ago this week, we began a journey that has just become better with each year. That is the benefit of marrying up.Getting married was not somethin

    August 15, 2014

  • Religion Briefs Aid group: American with Ebola improvingATLANTA (AP) - A second American who came down with Ebola in Liberia is now hospitalized in Atlanta.SIM missionary Nancy Writebol has joined Samaritan’s Purse Dr. Kent Brantly at Emory University Hospital, wher

    August 8, 2014